Coming next: The Second Factory →

Back to Library
Adoption & Product⚠️ Pitfall

The Demo Trap

The Problem

Your GenAI project demos brilliantly. Executives love it. The technology is impressive. The interface is elegant. The conversations feel natural. But when you check the usage data, you find 47 total sessions in production—and 43 of them were from your team testing it. You spent six months of engineering time and $180,000 in inference costs building a solution that solved the wrong problem exceptionally well. The real friction wasn't where you thought it was. Users didn't want a conversation; they wanted to complete a task as quickly as possible. Your chatbot added eight minutes to a process that used to take three. It converted at 38% when the old process converted at 87%. And it cost $60,000 per month to run. But it demos great.

The Principle

Demo success ≠ production value. The most impressive technology often solves problems that don't exist, while boring solutions fix problems that cost real money every day. Before building any AI solution, validate three things: 1. The problem exists and is painful enough to change behavior 2. The AI solution is actually faster/better than what exists today 3. You're measuring adoption, not just engagement Boring problems beat sexy solutions. Every time.

🎯

6 Steps to Take Action

  1. 1

    Measure problem frequency before solution coolness

    Don't ask 'Could we use AI for this?' Ask 'How many times per day does this problem cost us money?' If the answer is less than 10x per day, it's probably not worth automating.

  2. 2

    Start with the ugliest, most manual process

    If AI helps with something people already enjoy, you've added unnecessary complexity. If it helps with something people actively avoid, you've created real value.

  3. 3

    Demo to actual users before building, not after

    Show sketches and wireframes to 10 real users. If they don't immediately say 'This would save me so much time,' you're building the wrong thing.

  4. 4

    Track adoption weekly, not quarterly

    If usage isn't growing 20%+ week-over-week in the first month, you have a problem. Don't wait for quarterly reviews to discover nobody's using it.

  5. 5

    Compare to the status quo, not to nothing

    Don't ask 'Is this AI solution good?' Ask 'Is this AI solution better than what people do today?' Faster? Easier? Cheaper? If not, you're creating friction, not solving it.

  6. 6

    Set a kill date before you launch

    Decide in advance: 'If we don't have X active users by Y date, we shut it down.' Prevents the sunk cost fallacy from keeping bad projects alive.

💡 Inspired By

Every Fortune 500 company's 2024 GenAI roadmap. The ChatGPT wrapper epidemic. The belief that 'AI-powered' automatically means 'valuable.' And particularly the dozens of internal chatbots that impressed executives in demos but had zero active users six months later.

This is what Analytics Pitfalls & Principles is about: people helping people.

In Practice

ClassicMotors built an AI listing assistant that helped sellers list their cars through natural conversation. It was impressive in demos—executives loved watching it adapt to different car types and ask intelligent follow-up questions. The data told a different story: - Completion rate: 38% (vs. 87% for traditional form) - Average time: 8 minutes (vs. 3 minutes for form) - Returning seller adoption: 6% - Cost: $180,000 over three months The problem? The form was never the friction point. Sellers already knew what information ClassicMotors needed. They wanted to paste their VIN, upload photos, and move on with their day. The chatbot made them wait for the AI to ask questions they already had answers to. It turned parallel input (fill out multiple fields at once) into sequential conversation (answer one question, wait for next question). Sarah Chen, VP of Analytics, killed the project after five weeks. The four engineers were reassigned to fix the Excel spreadsheet that actually ran the auction business. The chatbot won an internal innovation award. The spreadsheet fix saved $2.4 million per year.

More on Adoption & Product

From the book

In the book there is a demo that wows the room and helps nobody, and a rough mockup that changes everything. The story is the difference between them.

This card is one of 57 drawn from The Auction Block by Brian Cariveau — the story of an analytics leader with 90 days to fix what the cards describe.

Each leadership pattern falls into a few pitfalls most often. Find your pattern.The Analytics Leadership Mirror: free, 5 minutes, no account